Have you had your first mince pie of the season yet? If you’re not the type to hand-make shortcrust pastry and soak your own boozy fruit, then it’s up to store-bought options for your festive snacking. But how do you find the Christmas mince pie with the most buttery pastry and rich, decadent filling?
The Better Homes and Gardens team, led by senior food editor Sarah Murphy, set out to discover the best supermarket fruit mince pie based on taste and price. In 2025, our mince pie taste test had samples ranging from very traditional to ‘adjacent to’ a mince pie. This year, we’re sticking to the classics, and only including traditional mince pies in our taste test (apart from a few novelty options we thought were extra special).
We blind-tasted 10 different Christmas fruit mince pie samples from Coles, Woolworths, Aldi and IGA. As it turns out, there was one clear winner, and it was as traditional as Christmas gets.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- The overall winner of our supermarket fruit mince pies taste test is Walker’s Fruit Mince Pies with a 7/10 from the panel and a 9/10 from our expert.
- We split our taste test into traditional and novelty fruit mince pies – the novelty fruit mince pies all ended up in the lower half of the ranking.
The Verdict
Mince pies were a controversial festive item among the panel – our tasters either loved or hated them. In true Christmassy fashion, the winner of our mince pie taste test ended up being the most traditional option, Walker’s Fruit Mince Pies. These sit in the middle for pricing, and won the hearts of our panel and expert for their classic buttery pastry and rich filling.
Walker’s Fruit Mince Pies
Traditional filling and delicious pastry.
Walker’s Fruit Mince Pies
Buttery shortcrust pastry and traditional filling.

Australian supermarket fruit mince pie taste test results
| Ranking | Name of product | Overall score out of 10 | Expert score out of 10 | Price per 100g |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Walker’s Fruit Mince Pies 6 pack | 7 | 9 | $2.55 |
| 2 | Walker’s Cranberry & Clementine Fruit Mince Pies 4 pack | 5.54 | 8 | $2.92 |
| 3 | Woolworths Christmas Gold Classic Fruit Mince Pies With Apple Brandy 6 pack | 5.54 | 6.5 | $3.06 |
| 4 | Coles Finest French Brandy Traditional Fruit Mince Pies | 370g | 5.27 | 6 | $2.30 |
| 5 | Aldi Festive Selection Fruit Mince Pies 6 Pack 360g | 5.1 | 6 | $1.05 |
| 6 | IGA Community Co Mince Pies 6 pack | 4.9 | 8 | $2.08 |
| 7 | Woolworths Gold Black Forest Inspired Fruit Mince Pies 6 pack (novelty) | 4.9 | 8 | $3.06 |
| 8 | Woolworths Australian Baked Mixed Berry Mince Pies 6 pack (novelty) | 4.7 | 5 | $1.74 |
| 9 | IGA Baker’s Oven Mince Pies | 4.6 | 4 | $1.17 |
| 10 | Coles Christmas Apple & Rhubarb Pies 6 Pack | 360g (novelty) | 3.8 | 5 | $1.74 |
Panel and expert winner

Walker’s Fruit Mince Pies 6 pack
Expert score: 9
Panel score: 7
The most traditional fruit mince pie from Walker’s topped our taste test ranking by a mile! With their signature buttery biscuit crust and a rich, classic filling, this one was a no-brainer for our panel and expert. Comments ranged from ‘sweet but not sickly’ to ‘tastes proper good’. The only downfall for our panellists? There were a few gaps in the filling, with some mentioning that the pies could have been filled more.
Our food expert Sarah Murphy said that the pastry was nice and crisp, and the mince filling was the perfect balance between traditional and not too boozy. She highly recommends this one for warming up in the oven, with a scoop of ice cream (of course!).
Best for
- Buttery, thick shortcrust pastry
- Rich, decadent filling
Price: $9.50
Available at Coles and Woolworths
The rest

Walker’s Cranberry & Clementine Fruit Mince Pies 4 pack
Expert score: 8
Panel score: 5.54
With an added level of fruit and candied peel, Walker’s Cranberry & Clementine Fruit Mince Pies came in second place for our panel. While very similar to their standard fruit mince pie, there was another layer of spice and sweetness in the filling. Most of our panel enjoyed it, but some found issue with the more intense flavour, calling it ‘overpowering’ and ‘too strong’.
Sarah loved the concentrated candied orange taste, but thought it may be too much for those that aren’t mince pie enthusiasts.
Best for
- Strong, candied orange flavour
- Intense, rich filling
Price: $7
Available at Woolworths

Woolworths Christmas Gold Classic Fruit Mince Pies With Apple Brandy 6 pack
Expert score: 6.5
Panel score: 5.54
For a classic supermarket option, our third place winner, Woolworths Christmas Gold Classic Fruit Mince Pies With Apple Brandy, is your best bet. With a crunchy sugar coating on top of the pie, and Christmas spices within the pastry as well as the filling, this sample was enjoyed by many. The let down? A doughy consistency in the pastry.
Best for
- Nice sugar crunch topping
- Plump raisins in filling
- Spiced pastry
Price: $11
Available at Woolworths

Coles Finest French Brandy Traditional Fruit Mince Pies | 370g
Expert score: 6
Panel score: 5.27
Coles Finest French Brandy Traditional Fruit Mince Pies sits in the middle of our ranking for supermarket mince pies. Our panel and expert thought they were a solid option, but had nothing very special or festive about them. Points were deducted for a more crumbly, lackluster pastry, but overall, they were decent enough that it wouldn’t be offensive to serve them at your next holiday party.
Best for
- Good filling to pastry ratio
- Great filling texture
Price: $8.50
Available at Coles

Aldi Festive Selection Fruit Mince Pies 6 Pack 360g
Expert score: 6
Panel score: 5.1
The thick lattice pie lid and solid ratio of pastry to filling was the standout for Aldi’s Festive Selection Fruit Mince Pies. Our panel loved not only how festive the pies looked, but the delicious crunch of the lattice as they bit into their sample piece. Unfortunately, the flavour of the filling was a let down for some, with mentions of an unusual aftertaste and ‘weird essence of liqueur’ (of which we can confirm there wasn’t any! according to the ingredients listed) .
Best for
- Thick lattice pie lid
- Wetter filling
Price: $13
Available at Aldi

IGA Community Co Mince Pies 6 pack
Expert score: 8
Panel score: 4.9
The IGA Community Co Mince Pies were a slightly controversial sample in our taste test. While many panellists felt that the pies were too strong and intense, mince pie lovers – including BHG digital editor Rupert Bickersteth – said it was the most mince pie of the samples in the whole test. With a distinct rum flavour and rich raisin filling, it certainly was the strongest option that our tasters tried. Sarah agreed with Rupert and other mince pie ‘experts’ (as they called themselves), that this sample was as close you’d get to the real homemade thing!
Best for
- Accurate, traditional filling
- Solid pastry to filling ratio
- Most alcohol-forward option
Price: $7.50
Available at IGA

Woolworths Gold Black Forest Inspired Fruit Mince Pies 6 pack (novelty)
Expert score: 8
Panel score: 4.9
Our first novelty fruit mince pie in the ranking is Woolworths Gold Black Forest Inspired Fruit Mince Pies. Deceivingly, these mince pies looked like delicious little chocolate treats, but to the dismay of many, were quite similar to that of a normal mince pie. The inclusion of tart cherries and a slight chocolate flavouring didn’t sell it for many of our panellists.
On the other hand, Sarah really enjoyed this sample, saying it was ‘quite nice’ but still too removed from a traditional mince pie to rank higher up in the list.
Best for
- Novelty filling and pastry
- Light spiced filling
Price: $11
Available at Woolworths

Woolworths Australian Baked Mixed Berry Mince Pies 6 pack (novelty)
Expert score: 5
Panel score: 4.7
The Australian Baked Mixed Berry Mince Pies from Woolworths had a nice pastry, but the mixed berry filling was confusing, rather than exciting, to our panel. One comment was simply ‘is this fig?’. Many did enjoy the mince filling, especially the more blended texture.
The texture of the pastry was also mentioned several times, with ‘claggy’ and ‘too soft’ being the standout comments.
Best for
- Good pastry flavour
- Nice mince filling
Price: $6.25
Available at Woolworths

IGA Baker’s Oven Fruit Mince Pies
Expert score: 4
Panel score: 4.6
IGA Baker’s Oven Fruit Mince Pies were not a hit with our panel or expert taste testers. The lattice pie topping was positively remarked upon, but the pastry and filling were overall a letdown. Comments included ‘quite pretty, but not very tasty’. If you’re looking for more of an aesthetic mince pie, then this could be the best option.
Best for
- Nice lattice pie topping
Price: $4
Available at IGA

Coles Christmas Apple & Rhubarb Pies 6 Pack | 360g (novelty)
Expert score: 5
Panel score: 3.8
Finally, in last place, is Coles Christmas Apple & Rhubarb Pies 6 Pack. The letdown for this sample was the overly sweet filling. We did have a few panel tasters that loved the apple and rhubarb pie flavour, but most found it untraditional, artificial and a ‘weird’ colour.
Sarah agreed on the most part, saying it was just a berry tart, not similar at all to a mince pie. As a standalone tart, without the Christmas mince pie connotations, she would’ve rated it higher.
Best for
- Sweet, jam-like filling
Price: $6.25
Available at Coles
How we tested the supermarket mince pies
We blind taste-tested 7 different supermarket fruit mince pies from Coles, Woolworths, Aldi and IGA. All samples were placed on identical trays and tasted without any accompaniments. We cut every mince pie into quarters so all the samples were evenly sized. None of the mince pies were heated up or accompanied with any condiments.
Samples were numbered from 1 to 10 to avoid bias, with 7-10 being the ‘novelty’ samples. Taste-testers shared their responses via an anonymous online form, ranking each mince pie sample out of ten for three criteria: taste, texture, and overall satisfaction. Taste-testers were also encouraged to leave constructive comments on what they liked and disliked about each sample.


How we selected which supermarket fruit mince pies to test
To be included in our Christmas mince pie taste test, products had to be widely available in supermarkets nationally. This meant choosing the most common brands available in a wide range of stores. All the fruit mince pies chosen were in stock at the time of purchase. We decided to only include mince pies that had traditional filling and were labelled as mince ‘pies’, apart from three novelty filling options. Several brands with ‘mince tarts’ were excluded. This was to help with the sample size, and ensure that it was appealing and available to all of our readers.
Products are chosen at the discretion of the Better Homes and Gardens editorial team, and no payment was received from brands or retailers to be featured in this taste test.